Obamacare Led To A Surge In Unnecessary Ambulance Rides, But Academics Say Medicare For All Won't Increase Usage

A paper from academics says that the final goal of the Affordable Care Act - Medicare For All - won't lead to more hospital stays. This is in defiance of data during ACA, where it led to higher costs for minor injuries because Obamacare made ambulances cheaper than Uber.How will more free medical treatment not lead to more medical treatment? The British NHS is an example. Though it is free, doctors are underpaid, morale is low, and wait times are high. They are not putting you in the hospital unless it is beyond necessary and end-of-life care may be...accelerated. 

A paper from academics says that the final goal of the Affordable Care Act - Medicare For All - won't lead to more hospital stays. This is in defiance of data during ACA, where it led to higher costs for minor injuries because Obamacare made ambulances cheaper than Uber.

How will more free medical treatment not lead to more medical treatment? The British NHS is an example. Though it is free, doctors are underpaid, morale is low, and wait times are high. They are not putting you in the hospital unless it is beyond necessary and end-of-life care may be...accelerated. 

The paper seeks to make a solid case for more politicization of health care - they argue that cutting back on the ACA would deprive more people of health care coverage than have received it and that Medicare For All will pay for itself. Yes, poor people will use more hospitals but rich people will use them less. Some of their figures are suspect. They claim that 1966's Medicare and Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act provided new coverage to about 10% of the U.S. population. Which means they are claiming over 30 million people in America were deprived of health insurance and suddenly. Since the actual number covered was 7 million, and only 15 percent of those could not get health insurance prior to that, it is hard to take their other claims seriously.(1) 

And the other reason it's difficult to accept this is they clearly went into writing the paper with a goal in mind and forced results to fit the narrative. They note that in the late 1960s hospitalizations by healthier people dropped while hospitalizations by older sick people went up. That is a sign of better medical care, not government funding. Were these healthy people hypochondriacs and doctors had enough? Did they age out and become part of the older group? Casual surveys of a column and a row can't give us meaningful context. 

(1) Forcing young people out of college under their parents' plans until age 26 was not helping anyone, it just drove costs up (as far as 700 percent) for families with insurance. 

Hank Campbell is an American science writer, author of the bestselling book 'Science Left Behind', and the founder of Science 2.0®, the world's largest independent science communications site. His work has appeared in the Wall Street Journal, USA Today, Wired, Chicago Tribune, CNN, and many more places.