PLOS One has been criticized again, this time America's most popular open access (no subscription required to read, scientists instead are forced to pay to publish) journal has been criticized for posting a paper that made references to a 'creator.'
Now, I have no particular issue with references to a Creator, but they seem odd in a science journal.
The paper got attention for that reason but the underlying flaw, that it passed 'peer review', got far less. Why? An obvious reason is that people want to believe they have been peer-reviewed, even though the evidence is obvious they probably haven't. PLOS publishes over 40,000 articles per year, most of them are not peer-reviewed. There aren't enough academics in existence to peer-review every journal that claims to be peer-reviewed. Most of them, and PLOS One, instead do editorial review. An editor checks off a few boxes and maybe it will be rejected outright and maybe it will go to peer review. Most of the time, it just gets published and the quality is irrelevant. They want that credit card charge to clear so if you are writing some fuzzy wuzzy paper with uncontrolled surveys it is going up, even though no one asked the awkward questions about the data and methodology that a regular journal would have asked.
When I first noted that years ago, you'd have thought I committed the science version of peeing on a Communion wafer. PLOS zealots came out in force to criticize me, PLOS itself took me off their embargo list and has refused to give us embargo access to any of their articles since. Of course all tens of thousands were thoroughly peer-reviewed, evangelists sneered at me, PLOS is awesome and I must be a shill for Big Journal.
Well, PLOS is Big Journal. Look at their financials and you see running PLOS nets you a cool $800,000 per year. If you make note of that, it is getting rationalized: San Francisco is expensive, they are competing with the private sector, etc. The exact arguments they use against corporate journals. And why such a high cost? Well, it takes expertise to format, editors, infrastructure; also arguments they didn't like when journals used them.